Handcrafted with Love,
Baked with Faith
Small-batch cookies made with real butter and timeless recipes from Cookeville, Tennessee
Our Story
Better Butter Cookie Company began in a small Cookeville, Tennessee kitchen with a simple belief: cookies should taste like they did when grandma made them. No shortcuts. No artificial ingredients. Just real butter, quality flour, and recipes that have stood the test of time.
As a Torah keeper, faith guides everything we do. We observe the Sabbath from Friday sunset to Saturday sunset, a time of rest and reflection that reminds us that good things can't be rushed. Our cookies are baked with that same patience and care.
What Makes Us Different
Every cookie we bake reflects our commitment to quality, tradition, and faith
🍪
Real Butter, Always
We never use margarine or vegetable shortening. The rich, creamy flavor of real butter is what makes our cookies unforgettable
.
📜
Ingredients You Can Pronounce
No artificial dyes, no preservatives, no fillers. If you can't pronounce it, we don't use it.
🌟
Small Batch Quality
We bake in small batches to ensure every cookie gets the attention it deserves. Quality over quantity, every single time.
The Cookie Camper
💛
Faith & Family Values
Our business is built on principles of honesty, integrity, and service. We believe in treating our customers like family and our cookies like the treasures they are.
Our vintage camper isn't just transportation—it's a mobile cookie experience. Fully restored and ready to bring fresh-baked joy to your wedding, birthday party, corporate event, or community gathering.
When the Cookie Camper arrives, so does the nostalgia, the sweetness, and the smiles.
About Me
I didn’t set out to be the “cookie lady.” I just loved baking. Then Crohn’s disease showed up when I was a kid, and after a tough hospitalization in 2012, I started reading labels like my life depended on it—because it did. That journey pushed me into health coaching so I could help others fight the same battle. And it’s why you’ll never see me selling neon-dyed, candy-stuffed cookies or store-bought shortcuts. If I can’t make it from scratch with ingredients you can pronounce, it doesn’t go on the menu. Period.
Better Butter began in the most old-fashioned way—I invited myself. My neighbors were selling freeze-dried candy at an event, and I showed up with cookies. By the second event, I was on my own, and people were lining up for the flavors that reminded them of their grandma’s cookies.
And the style? That’s just me having fun. I grew up on I Love Lucy, The Dick Van Dyke Show, Andy Griffith—those classic black-and-white laughs. So I leaned all the way in: 1950s housewife dresses, a vintage cookie camper, and cookies that taste like grandma’s. It’s nostalgia you can eat—a hug from the good ole days, wrapped in butter and sugar.
Better Butter Cookie Company is part faith, part grit, part fun. Because life’s too short for fake cookies.
Contact us
Book With Auntie Tee
Want cookies for your next event? Whether it’s a custom order box or booking the vintage Cookie Camper for weddings, parties, or corporate events—let’s make it happen.
Fill out the form below and tell me what you’re dreaming of. I’ll get back to you as soon as I can (just remember—I rest from Friday sunset to Saturday sunset).
Because no matter the event, cookies that taste like home always steal the show. 🍪✨
